Skip to main content

WomenEd Blogs

The school run should not be a leadership privilege

Tamara Caldwell

My children are teenagers, so the school run now involves fewer book bags and more urgent announcements about ingredients for DT. Usually at a point when buying ingredients is going to require a small miracle.

I love it, though. I like that ordinary bit of time together. I don’t require a meaningful conversation every morning, which is fortunate. Sometimes there is very little conversation at all. I still like being there.

Being a CEO gives me some control over my diary, and I am grateful for that. It also makes me think about the people working in education who have much less say over theirs. They are making sure other people’s children have a good day while trying to work out whether they can attend something important for their own.

It is a strange position for a profession that cares so much about families.

I know that a school timetable is a fairly substantial obstacle. My first teaching job was in Year 1. You can’t explain to thirty five-year-olds that you have a scheduling conflict and ask them to crack on. Colleagues need to know who is teaching, children need consistency and somebody has to arrange the cover. There are real difficulties to solve.

What troubles me is how quickly those difficulties can turn into a judgement about the person asking. A reasonable conversation about working arrangements can acquire an unpleasant undertone. Are you really committed? Are you sure this is the right time for promotion? Will you be able to cope?

I would like us to be a bit more careful with those questions. We may think we are checking that someone has considered the demands of a job. They may hear that having a family has made their ambition inconvenient.

When I wanted to complete my master’s in counselling psychology, I needed to work part time. A headteacher offered me an A level Psychology teaching job that made it possible. I could keep teaching and study alongside it. I went on to teach IB Psychology and take on sixth-form responsibilities.

I am glad somebody was willing to work with what I could offer at that point in my life. It would have been very easy to see my availability as a problem and end the conversation there.

There is already government guidance on flexible working in schools, along with practical resources for putting arrangements in place. We have somewhere to start. The harder part, I suspect, is making it feel acceptable to ask in the first place.

Most people can tell whether a policy is safe to use. They notice what happens to the colleague who leaves for a family commitment. They hear the little comments about someone working part time. They also notice whether a senior leader can go to a child’s event without producing an elaborate account of when the hours will be made up.

I don’t want flexibility to become a benefit reserved for people with enough seniority to arrange it quietly. Nor should colleagues without children be expected to absorb everybody else’s commitments. They have lives too. If an arrangement depends on the same person always staying late, it needs looking at again.

I would like leaders to be able to explain how decisions are made and to take responsibility for making them fair. That includes being honest when a particular request won’t work, while still being willing to discuss what might.

There will be days when work has to come first. There will be missed events, difficult diaries and arrangements that fall apart at short notice. I don’t think anybody expects a career in education to come with unlimited freedom. I do think people should be able to ask for a manageable working life without feeling that they have revealed a character flaw.

When I do the school run, I am exercising a degree of choice that plenty of very capable people do not have. I haven’t discovered a superior way of being a working mother. I have more control over my time.

Remembering that seems a useful place to begin, preferably before the next conversation about how everyone simply needs to manage their diary better.



About Tamara Caldwell

Tamara Caldwell is CEO of Impress Education. She began her teaching career in Year 1 in Newham before moving into A level and IB Psychology, later becoming an IB coordinator and second in charge of a sixth form. She holds a degree in Psychology from Goldsmiths, University of London, and a master’s in Counselling Psychology with an existential focus. Born in Battersea to a Jamaican family and raised in South and East London, Tamara brings an interest in identity, belonging and human relationships to her writing on education and leadership. She has also volunteered in schools and community settings in Ghana and Brazil, and is a mother of teenagers.

  • Hits: 94

Like what you see?

Share on your socials...